Page Body

Page Main

Post Main

Post Article

Don't Expect Tech to Care About Your Problems

Linked by Paul Ciano on June 2, 2017

Cathy O’Neil:

The entrepreneurs of Silicon Valley are undoubtedly finding many ways to make the world a better place – with tunnels, flying cars, interplanetary travel. Yet I can’t help noticing a growing divide between the problems people have and the problems tech companies are willing or able to solve.

This divide has two sources. The first is related to inequality: When people live in an elite bubble, they don’t experience the everyday frictions of normal life. So they focus on issues that would barely register for the rest of us workaday saps. That’s how you get Juicero, or for that matter Theranos, which was supposed to solve the problem of people who don’t like getting blood drawn. Even as someone who regularly faints at the doctor’s office, and whose veins are tricky to find, I don’t think that rises to the level of a real problem.

The bad news is that the divide has a second, less tractable part. It stems from a conflict, mostly unacknowledged, at some of the largest internet companies: They want our personal data, but they don’t want the transparency and responsibility that should come with it. While they generate billions of dollars of ad revenue with our information, they remain opaque and unaccountable.

In a reasonable negotiation, we’d offer up our personal data and attention in return for basic services like making sure our emotional health is protected and our democratic process hasn’t been undermined. But again, these are problems that tech giants have no incentive to address. Instead, researchers must construct their own data sets to learn that Facebook makes people unhappy, and journalists must beg readers for the data needed to understand how people are profiled and how internet advertising affects democracy.

Paul Ciano

Enjoyed this post?

Let me know you appreciate it by signing up for my newsletter.